Click Here to Subscribe to Grading and Excavation Magazine
Small Is Smart

You may print one copy of this page for personal use. Please report any other use to FORESTER COMMUNICATIONS, INC., using the online form at http://216.55.25.242/crv_report.html

Small Is Smart title graphicFor a growing number of grading and excavation contractors, skid-steer loaders aren't an option, they're a necessity. Here's a look at how these amazing machines can pay off, as well as some tips for buying the one that's just right for you.

By Greg Northcutt

Productivity
Reliability/Durability
Safety
Comfort/Convenience
Servicing
Financing

Don't let the trim, compact size of skid-steer loaders fool you. These multipurpose, four-wheeled mighty mites are exceptionally big around construction sites. Big in saving high labor costs. Big in saving precious time. Big in making money. Pound for pound, dollar for dollar, they're arguably the biggest and best value of any piece of grading or excavating equipment on the market today.

They're speedy, nimble, and affordable. Sticker prices for skid-steer loaders suitable for grading and excavating work generally are posted in the $20,000-$45,000 range. With engines ranging in power from about 45 to 105 hp, these machines measure about 7-9 ft. long without attachments, 5-6 ft. wide, and 6-7 ft. or so high and weigh 5,000-10,000 lb. They can spin completely around within their own length and can work easily in places too small for big iron and where high labor costs and tight schedules rule out the use of hand tools.

What's more, no other machine in the price range of skid-steer loaders can do so many jobs so well. Thanks to an astonishing range of attachments---one manufacturer counts more than 75 for some of its models---these no-nonsense machines can master just about any task needed for excavating and grading work in tight places. That's an increasingly valuable trait as the size of building sites, particularly in metropolitan areas, continues to shrink. Even in open areas, skid-steer loaders can still outperform bigger equipment in certain jobs and situations.

Want to dig a trench? Attach a backhoe. When you're done digging, use a bucket to backfill the trench. Then switch to a trench compactor to finish the job.

Maybe your building site is covered with brush. Hook on a brush-cutting attachment. Next, use a grapple attachment to pile or load brush and tree cuttings. Change to a bucket for some rough excavating and grading. To complete the job, attach a laser-guided, six-way blade for the finish grading.

If your work site includes soils too soft for wheeled equipment or slopes where you need more traction, slip a pair of steel tracks over the wheels. If access to your job means crossing such sensitive surfaces as a blacktop driveway or a lawn, use rubber tracks instead.

Thomas skid-steer
Thoams skid-steer loader with grading attachment

When you're not moving dirt or debris, you can boost productivity even more by using your skid-steer loader to move concrete forms, spot pallets of sod, blocks, and who-knows-what-else. If winter weather closes down construction projects, attach a blade, a bucket, or a snow blower to fatten up those lean times with income from snow-removal work.

They Wouldn't Work Without Their Skid-Steer Loaders

Bohnsack and Hennen Excavating in Prior Lake, MN. has been using skid-steer loaders for at least 20 years. currently, the company operates three of them in addition to a dozen pieces of large equipment, such as dozers and track excavators. The company, operated by Leroy Bohnsack and his son, Mike, does excavating and finish-grading work for residential construction contractors in the Minneapolis-St. Paul area.

"We wouldn't think about working without our skid-steer loaders," says Mike. "They ;et us work in tight spots where we can't get in with any of our other equipment. They sure beat a shovel. Also, our finished product is a lot better than it would be with larger equipment. because we can work much closer to buildings without causing foundations to crack. It's pretty easy to learn how to run a skid-steer loader. But to be a really good operator takes a little more time."

Crews use smooth-edge buckets for digging, hauling, loading and backfilling, and---in addition to a grading bar---final-grading landscapes. Other attachments for the skid-steer loaders include a sweeper for cleaning streets in front of their jobs and sprucing up the company's shop and yard area, a snow bucket and a hydraulic breaker. The breaker is used in demolition work to break large chunks of concrete removed by their large excavator into smaller pieces for loading into trucks. The company no longer has a tiller attachment. The tool did a good job, says Mike, but it wasn't fast enough to fit their construction schedules.

The company has two Bobcat Model 763 skid-steer loaders (46 hp, 1,500-lb. rated operating capacity). One of their main jobs is working inside basement excavations to backfill footings. "We dump sand or rock, which we're going to spread in the basement, to make a ramp into the basement," Mike explains. "Then we drive the loader over the wall and down into the basement. When we're finished with the work, we use a large excavator to lift out the machine."

From start to finish takes about 45 minutes for a 1,000 square ft. basement, he reports. Usually backfilling a typical split-entry basement inside and out can be completed in three or four hours using one of the skid-steer loaders. The machines are also used to backfill garages and haul materials, such as decorative or drain tile rock.

Each of the two loaders is equipped with rubber tracks for working in wet spring conditions. However, the tracks remain on the machines year-round. The flotation and improved traction with these tracks make them better machines in most any condition, especially when working close to swamps or ponds or on sandy soil, Mike notes.

The company's other skid-steer loader is a Bobcat Model 973 (73.5 hp, 2,400-lb. load rated operating capacity). With more power and lifting ability than the other two, this machine is excellent for jobs that require a lot of pushing dirt or loading trucks, Mike says.

The compact size of skid-steer loaders also pays off with lower transportation costs. Compared to larger, heavier equipment, you can haul skid-steer loaders to the job site using smaller, less expensive trucks and trailers than required for bigger machines. In turn, that means lower insurance and tax rates and less stringent driver licensing requirements.

Add it all up, and skid-steer loaders make plenty of good dollars and sense for a growing number of grading and excavating contractors. Skid-steer loaders were once dismissed by skeptics as more toy than tool, but now many contractors in the industry wouldn't think of leaving the shop without their trusty skid-steer loaders.

More than a few enterprising equipment operators have used skid-steer loaders as their ticket to self-employment as grading and excavating contractors. That fact hasn't been lost on the full-line equipment manufacturers either. They see sales of skid-steer loaders to these entrepreneurs as an opportunity to form long-term relationships with customers who will upgrade to larger equipment as their businesses grow.

Skid-steer loaders have charged into the construction market in a big way in the 1990s. Peter Mabee, product and marketing manager for skid-steer-loader maker Thomas Equipment Ltd. in Mars Hill, ME, reports that demand for the machines in the United States has grown at a "phenomenal rate," increasing 140% since 1991 to yearly sales of more than 50,000 units. These machines now represent the largest single segment of the construction-equipment market with respect to units sold annually.

"In the past few years, the demand---in terms of machine size and capacity---has shifted," Mabee points out. "The market had been traditionally dominated by midsize units with a rated lift capacity of around 1,300 pounds. The demand has been steadily growing for skid-steer loaders with larger capacity and better performance."

"Everywhere you go, contractors want to buy skid-steer loaders because they're so versatile," reports Rod Osterloh, chief operating officer for Hecla Industries in Hecla, SD, which makes Patriot skid-steer loaders. "A contractor may use a large wheel loader for big work but will use a skid-steer loader for final work in smaller areas and close to buildings. They make a lot of construction jobs go a lot faster. They're the right tool for many applications."

Buyers include large construction firms, which have found that skid-steer loaders can fit into their equipment fleet and provide a good return on their investment. As long as the economy stays strong, say manufacturers, sales of skid-steer loaders should continue climbing for at least the next few years. The growing popularity of these machines reflects several factors:

  • construction contractors' increased appreciation of the profit ability of skid-steer loaders;
  • continued development of an ever-widening range of attachments ("With so many different attachments available now, use of a skid-steer loader is limited only by your creativity," remarks George Chaney, compact products sales manager for JCB Inc. in White March, MD);
  • a universal mounting system that allows various attachments to be used on different makes of machines;
  • technological advances in skid-steer-loader features, including more powerful units; and
  • greatly improved reliability and durability compared to some of the machines in the past.
Hecla Patriot skid-steer
Hecla Patriot skid-steer loader

Skid-steer loaders have come a long way from their humble beginnings more than 40 years ago on a farm in Minnesota. That's when a turkey grower, tired of cleaning out manure from his barn using hand tools, announced that he wanted a machine with forks that would do the job faster and easier. It had to be small and maneuverable enough to clean around the barn's many posts. Two brothers who ran a nearby blacksmith and machine shop accepted the challenge.

Melrose Bobcat skid-steer
Melroe Bobcat skid-steer loader

The result was a small, self-propelled, three-wheeled machine: two drive wheels in front, a manure fork attached to two lift arms, a small caster wheel in the rear, and a 6-hp engine. It featured two steering levers-one for each drive wheel-and could turn 360° on a dime. The machine attracted the attention and interest of the Melroe Manufacturing Company in Gwinner, ND, which acquired rights to the machine. Refining the concept, Melroe enlarged the machine, beefed up its power, added another wheel, and in 1960 introduced the world's first four-wheel-drive skid-steer loader.

Skid steering is the key to the agility of these machines, which in turn hinges on the ratio of the loader's tire-tread width to wheelbase and on the machine's balance. With conventional four-wheel motorized vehicles, the two rear wheels are mounted onto a fixed axle to roll either forward or backward, while the front two wheels can be turned to the right or left as they roll forward or backward. All four wheels on a skid-steer loader are mounted onto fixed axles and run only straight ahead or straight back.

Also, unlike conventional four-wheel, self-propelled vehicles, which have one drive system for two or all four wheels, skid-steer loaders have two independent transmissions. One controls the two right wheels; the other controls the left two. This setup provides two ways to change the direction of travel. To turn the machine to the left and away from a wall, for example, you stop rotation of the two left tires by keeping their steering control in neutral. Then, using the right steering control, you forward rotate the two right tires. This causes the machine to skid to the left, giving the machine its skid-steer feature. For a faster spin turn, as when loading dirt from a pile into a truck, you forward-rotate tires on one side while reversing tire rotation on the other side.

Whether the skid-steer loader turns or pivots on the front or the rear axle depends on how weight is distributed, explains Lynn Roesler, skid-steer-loader products manager for Melroe Company. "Skid-steer loaders are designed so that, without a load on the bucket, about 70 percent of the machine's weight is on the rear axles and about 30 percent is on the front axles. With most of the load on the rear axles, the machine turns or pivots on the rear wheels, and the front wheels skid right or left.

"When the bucket is loaded or another tool is attached, weight distribution reverses. Now most of the weight is on the front axles, and the rear wheels skid as the machine turns or spins. The optimum tread width-to-wheelbase ratio enables a properly designed skid-steer loader to turn without consuming excess engine power or causing excess tire wear."

At one time, belts, gears, shafts, and clutches were used to transmit engine power to the wheels of skid-steer loaders. Today, hydrostatic transmissions do the job using hydraulic fluid, pumps, and motors. Hydrostatic transmissions operate much more smoothly than mechanical-drive systems. Also, controls with hydrostatic systems respond the instant you move them, unlike the slight delays you experience when you engage clutch-operated mechanical drives. Hydrostatic systems require less servicing than mechanical transmissions. However, servicing hydrostatic systems, particularly the pumps, requires a much higher level of technical expertise. Hydraulics is also used to control the lift arms or booms and the buckets, pallet forks, and other tools attached to them.

JCB Robot skid-steer
JCB Robot skid-steer loader

Over the years, skid-steer-loader manufacturers have continued to improve and refine their products. A few manufacturers have developed hybrids. For example, JCB offers a machine that it calls a skid-steer backhoe loader. On the front is a pair of lift arms, which can be fitted with buckets or a wide variety of other attachments using a universal quick-hitch system. A backhoe is mounted on the rear-not as an attachment but as an integral part of the machine. Also, the backhoe bucket can be unpinned and replaced with such attachments as a hydraulic breaker, auger, or clam bucket. JCB reports that this machine offers the performance and maneuverability of a 1,350-lb.-rated operating-capacity loader and the digging performance of a 3-ton excavator.

Takeuchi compact track loader
Takeuchi TL 26 compact track loader

Another hybrid, a machine similar in size and performance to the larger, more powerful skid-steer loaders, features a dedicated track system instead of wheels. These compact track loaders offer improved flotation for working on soft and muddy ground and increased traction on uneven terrain. Also, they're more versatile than a crawler dozer because they can be used with a bucket and many other types of attachments, notes Rex Hayes, product sales manager for Takeuchi in Buford, GA, which makes the TL26 compact rubber-track loader. He compares it to a conventional skid-steer loader: "Whenever the tires of a skid-steer loader are spinning as you're digging, you're wasting power. Compact track loaders have much greater traction and can make more efficient use of the machine's power for digging. That can be important when excavating tough, heavy soils.

"Also, because of increased flotation, a compact track loader lets you get back to rough grading sooner after a rain than a wheeled skid-steer loader does. If you gain two extra working days a month, that's a total of 24 more days a year. That can put a lot of extra money in your pocket."

Gehl skid-steer loader
Gehl skid-steer loader

Manufacturers offer a large selection of different skid-steer-loader models, features, options, and accessories. To help put the competitive claims and features in perspective, Larry James, manager of distribution development/planning for Gehl Company in West Bend, WI, offers this thought: "No company attempts to build a bad product. Often the differences between various skid-steer-loader brands reflect differences in engineering philosophies and marketing approaches."

That still leaves you, the buyer, with the task of sorting through all the choices when picking the skid-steer loader that best matches your needs. To help narrow and simplify your search, here's a list of some of the factors to consider while shopping:


Productivity

Breakout Force. For a grading or excavation contractor, this is probably the single most important indicator of a skid-steer loader's performance. This is the amount of force applied by the machine's lift arm and bucket cylinders at the bucket lip. The more breakout force, the faster and easier you can fill the bucket, which is especially important for keeping cycle times short when digging in heavy, tough conditions.

A Versatile Machine for a Large Contractor

Steve McWilliams, president of New Design in Denver, CO, knew the value of a skid-steer loader from previous experience when he started the general-highway and heavy-construction company in the mid-1908s.

"It's a very versatile piece of equipment," he says, "We use the loaders mostly to increase productivity of work once done by hand. They don't require extremely skilled operators, and they reduce injuries associated with manual labor."

Skid-steer loaders have been in his equipment fleet from the beginning. Today, that flee numbers about 300 pieces of equipment and includes tractor-loader backhoes, front-end loaders, large excavators, graders, and half a dozen or so skid-steer loaders.

The company uses two Gehl skid-steer loader models---the 4635 (44 hp, 1,425-lb. SAE operating capacity) and the 5635 (60 hp, 1,800-lb. SAE operating capacity).

They're primarily used with smooth-edge buckets for final grading on curb and gutter projects and for hauling concrete forms and other materials. However, they're also used with a variety of attachments to increase productivity in a wide range of work. These tools include a hydraulic breaker, a sweeper, and a pavement planer.

Load-Lifting Ability. Another good measure of a skid-steer loader's value is its ability to lift loads. Most manufacturers report this as rated operating capacity. Based on the Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) Standard J818, it equals 50% of the load required to tip the skid-steer loader forward. For best performance in grading and excavating work, manufacturers recommend skid-steer loaders with at least a 1,500-lb. rated operating capacity. Because compact track loaders normally operate on rougher, steeper terrain, they're subject to more unstable working conditions than skid-steer loaders are. To account for this, the rated operating capacity (SAE J818) for compact track loaders represents 35% of the tipping load.

Type of Lift Path. Since skid-steer loaders are often used to load trucks, lift height (the height from ground to bucket hinge pin) and reach (the dump reach at full height) are also important numbers to check. Here, the path of the loader's lift arms as they go up and down makes a difference. Most machines have a radius lift: The ends of the arms mimic an arc as they raise and lower. They offer the longest reach in the middle part of this path. Loaders with a vertical lift path---ends of the loader arm raise and lower in more or less a straight up-and-down motion---offer the greatest reach at the top of their lift path. As a result, this lift path is best for truck-loading chores. The lift path also affects the rated operating capacity. Because it keeps the load closer to the machine, a skid-steer loader with a vertical path will have a higher rated operating capacity than an otherwise identical skid-steer loader with a radius lift. For example, one manufacturer produces two different skid-steer-loader models identical in every way except for lift-arm design and a 21-lb. difference in operating weight. The model with the radius lift path has a 1,900-lb. rated operating capacity. That's 500 lb. less than the rated operating capacity of the slightly lighter model with the vertical lift path.

Wheelbase. For the past several years, some skid-steer-loader manufacturers have been offering models with longer wheelbases than has been customary. Because of the physics involved, this increases the rated operating capacity of a given machine. It also produces a smoother ride. Depending on typical carry distances and length of the workday, the increased comfort alone might be enough to justify the added cost.

Engine Size. As noted earlier, skid-steer loaders used by grading and excavating contractors typically have engines with no less than 45 hp. Larger skid-steer loaders with larger engines will, of course, provide more tractive power and breakout force. Horsepower ratings, however, don't tell the whole story since some machines may be engineered to use engine power more efficiently than others do.

"Buy a skid-steer loader with the power and performance to do the work you want to do today, plus a little bit more," suggests Hecla's Osterloh. "That way you'll be able to handle more work that might come your way tomorrow."

Wheels Versus Tracks. Flat tires aren't a problem with dedicated track machines. Also, they'll let you keep working when terrain and/or soft ground conditions stop a wheeled skid-steer loader. But there are trade-offs. A compact track loader can't travel as fast on solid ground as a similar-size skid-steer loader on wheels. In addition, the sticker price of the tracked machine may be 5-10% higher than for a similar-size skid-steer loader on wheels. On the other hand, the extra productivity of the track loader as a result of its ability to work in wetter soil conditions could make up for the difference in price, notes Takeuchi's Hayes.

"If a compact track loader lets you work 15 additional days a year, bringing in $60 per hour for an eight-hour day, you'd earn an extra $7,200," he notes. "If most of your work involves hard or improved surfaces, you'll probably be happier with a conventional skid-steer loader. But if you're working on dirt at least 40 percent of the time, a compact track loader is worth considering."

Over-the-Wheel Tracks. A number of skid-steer-loader owners enjoy the benefits of tracks by equipping their machines with rubber or steel tracks that fit over the wheels. Many of these owners keep tracks on the machines year-round.

Hydraulic Flow. Some attachments, such as a dozer blade or grader, require auxiliary hydraulics. The variety of these tools continues to increase. Several skid-steer-loader manufacturers offer high-flow hydraulics to operate such attachments as some trenchers, pavement planers, and wheel saws that require extra hydraulic power. Depending on your range of services, that may or may not be a consideration.

Other Productivity Considerations. Angle of bucket rollback and dump angle also affect productivity. The farther back the bucket rolls at ground level, the more material you can handle at a time. The greater the dump angle, the faster you can unload it. And of course other factors, such as the time required to complete one loading-dumping cycle, determine production levels, as does travel speed. Some skid-steer loaders can zip along at a pace of 10 mph or faster.


Reliability/Durability

In most brands of skid-steer loaders, drive chains turn the front and rear axles. At least one line of loaders uses gears instead of chains to transmit power from the hydrostatic motors to the axles. The manufacturers claim advantages for each system: Chain drives cost less and are fairly easy to service. Gear drives are more durable and require no periodic adjustment, as do some chain drives.


Safety

Features. Manufacturers equip their skid-steer loaders with a number of features designed to minimize the risk of injuries when operating the machines. These features include lock-out systems that prevent use of hydraulic controls until you are seated with seat belt fastened and seat bar lowered, a ROPS/FOPS (roll-over protective structure/falling object protective structure)-approved cab, supports to prevent the lift arms from lowering accidentally when servicing or repairing the machine, front and rear lights, and back-up alarms.

Visibility. The view from the operator's seat is, of course, a key safety consideration. Check visibility to the front, sides, and rear.


Comfort/Convenience

Controls. Several different types of controls are used to steer skid-steer loaders and operate the lift arms and buckets, depending on manufacture.

In one type, you use hand and foot controls, steer by using a lever for each hand, raise and lower the lift arms with one foot, and control the bucket with the other foot. In another, you use your hands to steer and operate the boom and bucket. With a third type, you steer using one lever and operate the bucket and lift arms with a joystick.

Some manufacturers offer several choices. Which method is best? Whichever one you get used to, say many veteran operators.

Features. A number of options and accessories are available for most skid-steer loaders that can increase the usefulness, comfort, and convenience of the machines. For example:

  • enclosed, heated cab;
  • electronic monitoring of vital engine conditions and emergency shutdown to protect engine from catastrophic damage from low oil pressure or overheating;
  • suspension seat (well worth the extra cost, say those who have one);
  • hydraulic self-leveling bucket (a nifty feature in some applications that makes your job easier by keeping loads level throughout the entire loader arc when lifting and lowering);
  • sound insulation to reduce machine noise; and
  • top and rear windows to protect you from weather and help lower noise levels.


Servicing

In general, today's skid-steer loaders are much easier to service than those of the past. This is demonstrated by such features as a swing-open rear door for speedy access to the engine components, easy-to-reach service items such as filters and fluid-level indicators, a tip-up cab to reach hydrostatic system components quickly, and quick-release pins and panels. Ease of service is an important feature.

Daewoo skid-steer loader
Daewoo skid-steer loader

"Skid-steer loaders are being used more heavily under more adverse conditions than they once were," says Kim Robinson, vice president of sales and marketing for Daewoo in Suwanee, GA. "That means more frequent oil and filter changes and other servicing. The easier the machine is to service, the more likely it will be serviced when needed."


Financing

This can be a critical item, especially if you're starting your business.

Bob Davis, national accounts manager for Compact Technologies headquartered in Port Washington, WI, offers this advice: "In addition to considering factors such as product quality and good support from the factory and dealer, you should also select from manufacturers that can respond to your need for financing."

GX

Erosion Control Magazine | Grading and Excavation Contractor Magazine
MSW Management Magazine | Stormwater Magazine
Forester Communications | E-mail Us

|


Copyright 1999-2001 FORESTER COMMUNICATIONS, INC
P.O. Box 3100
Santa Barbara, CA 93130
805-681-1300 .