Better to Light a Candle

No matter what kind of construction work you're involved in, chances are you do at least part of it at night or in periods of reduced illumination—and chances are better still that the future promises even more of the same.

By John Trotti


 
 
What Kinds of Lights Are Available?
Reflectors
Lighting the Way to Job-Site Safety

Why? Lots of reasons, none more important to you than the economics of watching machinery that cost you tens or even hundreds of dollars an hour sitting around idle half the time rather than doing what they’re designed to do. Then, too, Departments of Transportation increasingly are restricting work along highways to off-peak hours where construction activities will necessitate lane closures, and as you’re well aware, work proceeds around the clock for most heavy construction projects. So what does this mean to you? Chances are you’ll have your crews working under lights almost as often as your favorite ball team, so you’d do well to study up.

What Kinds of Lights Are Available?

The majority of portable lighting systems on the market make use of high-pressure sodium (HPS), metal halide (MH), or tungsten halogen (TH) bulbs for illuminance (see Tables 1 and 2 for characteristics and capacities).

Table 1. Characteristics of Available Light Sources

Light Source

High-Pressure Sodium

Metal Halide

Tungsten Halogen

Watts per Floodlight

1,000

1,000

1,000

Initial Lumens

140,000

110,000

21,500

Mean Lumens

126,000 (92%)

88,000 (80%)

20,850 (97%)

Average Life (hours)

24,000

12,000

2,000

Color

Soft Orange

Bright White

Natural Daylight

Features

High lumen output; low lumen depreciation glare; low total system cost; fast restrike

High lumen output; good color rendition and overall lighting

Lowest initial cost; instant on; no ballasts; natural daylight color; good light aiming

Table 2. Lighting Capacity: Approximate Area Illuminated by 1 Foot-Candle

 

Avg. Foot-Candles

ft.2

ac.

m2

ha

HPS

0.5

105,000

2.41

9,755

0.98

MH

0.5

82,000

1.88

7,618

0.76

TH

0.5

26,500

0.61

2,462

0.25

Illuminance is the measurement of how bright a point source of light appears to the eye. It is measured in foot-candles or lux (see box). The foot-candle is defined as the illuminance on a uniform surface 1 ft. away from the light of one candle and is equal to 1 lumen/ft.2 This means a light source’s output of 1 lumen flowing through a sphere with a surface area equal to 1 ft.2 would produce an illuminance of 1 foot-candle on the surface of the sphere.

1 foot-candle equals 1 lumen/ft._, while 1 lux is equal to 1 lumen/m2

To convert from foot-candles to lux, multiply foot-candles by 10.76391

To convert from lux to foot-candles, multiply lux by 0.092903044

To determine what light-source output (L0 in lumens) would be required to produce an illuminance of 1 foot-candle at a distance of 1 ft., the formula is Lo/A, where Lo is the light-source output in lumens and A is the surface area in square feet of a sphere centered on the light source (see Figure 1). Thus, at a distance of 1 ft., A = 4 p ft2; so when I = 1 foot-candle, Lo = IA = 4 p lumens, which is approximately 12.57 lumens. In other words, for a light meter to read 1 foot-candle from a uniform point source of light that is 1 ft. away, a light source of about 12.57 lumens is required.

In general terms: I = Lo/(4 p d2) assuming the light can be considered a uniform point source (no reflector). From this, one can determine a light bulb’s minimum peak illuminance when one knows its specified initial output rating) and the distance to the observer. This is illustrated in Figure 2, showing the illuminance curves for lights of three different initial output ratings in lumens.

The nationally recognized standard of 0.1 foot-candle as a maximum level of light spillage off a property is indicated by the dotted line. If codes were designed to reflect this standard (or others), the formula for determining light placement could be as follows:

For a light bulb with an output rating of Lo (lumens) and a code limiting illuminance to less than I (foot-candles), the minimum allowable distance from property line to the bulb would be d, where: d = Ö (Lo / [4 p I]).

Reflectors

In the case of a light source within a reflector, the illuminance is increased because the light is being directed into a cone rather than in a sphere, as is the case with no reflector. The surface area of the spherical section of the cone (the bowl shape) is the area illuminated by the light source. This area is given by A = 2 p d2 (1 - cos [q /2]) so that the general illuminance formula for illuminance: I = Lo/A becomes I = Lo/2p d2 (1 - cos [q /2]).

Note that when q = 360º (no reflector), I = Lo/(4p d2).

From this, one can determine a reflected light bulb’s minimum peak illuminance (foot-candles) when one knows its specified initial output rating (lumens), the angle (degrees) of the light cone and the distance (feet) to the observer. For example, a 60-W (840-lumen) floodlight creating a 90º light cone would have to be placed almost 50 ft. farther away to achieve an illuminance level of 0.1 foot-candle.

This shows the energy savings that can be obtained by using properly directed lighting. By not spraying light indiscriminately as is done with unshielded fixtures, the desired illuminance level can be maintained by focusing the light to the proper location and reducing the light bulb’s power consumption.

In the construction industry, so much is said about job-site safety that it’s easy to think you have heard it all. The reality is that new safety issues frequently arise that contractors must address.

Job-site lighting is a perfect example. Today’s jobs have tighter deadlines and stricter regulations that are causing contractors to work during nontraditional hours. These factors force contractors to work in the early morning and late evening and into the night when nature simply cannot provide a safe amount of light.

In response to such conditions, contractors have turned to an alternate source of light: portable light towers. But all portable light towers are not the same, and many factors need to be considered when selecting and setting up light towers to ensure that the most efficient and safe job-site lighting is provided.

What to Look For

Because light towers are often a necessary obstruction on a job site, contractors need the most light from the fewest towers. To determine how much light a given tower can deliver, look at the source of the light: the lamp and the fixture.

Most light-tower manufacturers recommend and utilize 1,000-W lamps. The 1,000-W units are cost-effective and durable and deliver an excellent amount of light–up to 110,000 lumens in a perfect, nonreflective environment.

When placed in a coaxial (round) fixture, most of a lamp’s light output is reflected off the fixture surface, dropping light output to far below the lamp’s capability. Independent testing has shown that fixtures offering the most direct, nonreflective light output, such as parallel (oval) lamp fixtures, provide the most usable lumens directly to the job site.

Additionally, parallel lamp fixtures provide a more even distribution of light over the entire job site. Coaxial fixtures will typically produce spots of light, referred to as "hot spots," that are extremely brighter than the rest of the illuminated area.

On job sites, space is at a premium, and the addition of more equipment can lead to congestion and unsafe conditions. To combat this problem, contractors should look for light towers with a compact design. Compact units can save valuable space on a job site and might allow a contractor to close only a single lane of traffic; for example, to relieve congestion problems often associated with road construction and improvement projects. Compact units are also lighter, leading to better maneuverability, and are easier to ship, transport, and store for contractors, distributors, and rental houses.

How Many Towers Do You Need?

The Illuminating Engineering Society, a group of experts from the lighting industry, established the guidelines listed below to help contractors determine how many foot-candles of light particular job sites require. A foot-candle is the intensity of light per square foot of a surface area and can be measured with a light meter.

Job Site

Foot-Candles

Airport

0.5—2.0

Explosives Handling

30.0

General Construction

10.0

Excavation

2.0

Haul Roads and Industrial Roadways

0.5—1.0

Industrial Yard/Material Handling

5.0

Loading and Unloading

20.0

Parking Areas

1.0—5.0

Piers

20

Railroad Yards, Switching

2.0

Quarries and Open-Pit Mining

5.0

Sports Fields/Recreational

10.0—50.0

How many foot-candles a light tower can provide depends on many factors. Are you working on black dirt, concrete, or asphalt? Obviously a contractor might need more light towers to reach the recommended foot-candle measurement if he’s working on black dirt than if working on concrete. Is the sky clear or is it cloudy? A clear, moonlit night, for example, might require fewer light towers than an evening with overcast skies.

Every application must be evaluated with these considerations in order to determine how many light towers are necessary to safely light each site.

Setting Up

When setting up a light tower, always level the unit completely before extending the mast. Position the fixtures at the highest location possible to minimize glare on or at the work surface. On typical job sites, the fixtures should be tilted 20º toward the work area.

Contractors can further reduce glare by adding a visor to each fixture. A visor is, essentially, a piece of aluminum bent to the shape or curve of the fixture to capture excess reflected light and direct it both toward the job site and away from traffic, residential areas, and so on. Visors can provide as much as a 13% increase to a fixture’s usable light. Most manufacturers offer visors as optional equipment.

Other Safety Considerations

Just as job-site lighting is a key safety consideration, so is noise contamination, and adding another piece of equipment to an already busy job site can bring noise to a dangerous level. Many light-tower manufacturers have minimized vibration noise with heavy-duty enclosures and well-mounted engines. Some light towers also offer sound attenuation packages to further reduce noise levels. A light tower’s noise level should be no more than 65 dba.

Many light towers feature a mechanism that locks down the tower and prevents it from extending inadvertently when towing. Other safety features include self-locking stabilizers and captive latches on the tower support. These latches have eliminated the need for troublesome pins, resulting in a safer and simpler unit. Some light towers also feature what’s referred to as a "ground rod," which grounds the units to protect operators from electrical shock.

A Wrap-Up

To stay competitive, contractors are forced to do their work at all hours of the day regardless of the natural light available. To keep their job sites safe and productive, contractors must be aware of what manufacturers are doing to improve light towers and what their specific lighting needs are.

Jerry Greenquist, vice president of sales and marketing at Allmand Bros. Inc.

 

 
 

About | Subscribe | Current Issue | News | Events | Services
Register | Discussion  | Advertise | Contact Us | Search | Jobs

Erosion Control Magazine | MSW Management Magazine
Stormwater Magazine | Forester Communications

© 2001 Forester Communications, Inc.