|
Of the many things we
can be thinking about as summer approaches, for those of us in some
locales, seasonal flooding is near the top of the list. Although
many communities' current priority is grappling with NPDES
Phase II requirements, even there sorely needed flood-control measures
can eat up the bulk of a capital improvement budget. They also garner
greater attention when they don't work; people might be mildly
concerned or even diligently watchful about water quality most of
the time, but when a washed-out road cuts them off from their neighborhood
or when their living room is filling with mud, their attention is
riveted.
Getting the public to
support funding for stormwater and flood-control initiatives can
be a bit like the cautionary children's tale about the monkeys
in the rain forest: Although perfectly capable of building a rudimentary
shelter, they rarely do, and they find themselves drenched and unhappy
every time it rains. Once the rain stops, they forget about the
urgency of building and spend their time frolicking insteaduntil
the next storm, when they once more sit wailing and dripping under
the leaves.
A small-scale example
of reacting after the rains start left an impression on me years
ago. I grew up in a desert community crisscrossed with "dry
washes," or arroyos. Parched for most of the year, during flash
floods these corridors can channel a literal wall of water moving
at more than 10 miles an hour, eroding their banks. Nearly 20 years
ago, during what was termed a 100-year flood, an astute producer
from the evening news set up a camera near the bank of a flooded
arroyo, let it run, and eventually captured on film a brand-new
two-story office building toppling as the water relentlessly carved
the ground out from under it. As the footage was endlessly replayed
on television, zoning restrictions suddenly got a closer look. The
situation plays out on a large scale all over the country.
Some cities, such as
Tulsa, OK, are especially successful at using what they've
learned through soggy experience. In the '80s, Tulsa County
(in the Midwest's "Tornado Alley") earned the dubious
distinction of being declared a flood disaster area by the federal
government more frequently than any other area in the US. A massive
and deadly flash flood on Memorial Day in 1984 prompted Tulsa to
develop wide-ranging floodplain and stormwater management measures,
including a flood-alert system, and residents have since approved
millions of dollars needed for capital improvements. Houses have
been cleared from flood-prone areas of the city. Both FEMA and the
Association of State Floodplain Managers have singled out Tulsa
for its outstanding floodplain management program.
Even the best planning
can't avert all damage, but having a strong system in place
beforehand certainly helps. In 1980, Fort Collins, CO, created one
of the country's earliest stormwater utilities, which funded
drainage improvements over the next two decades. When a 500-year
flood hit the city in the summer of 1997, the destruction was tremendous:
five deaths and hundreds of millions of dollars in property damage.
However, the city credits the utility's improvements for preventing
even worse consequences. Since 1997, the utility has continued its
floodplain management programincluding new restrictions on
where development can occurand formulated new rainfall criteria
to use in designing stormwater facilities. Since the flood, too,
the residents of Fort Collins have been extremely supportive of
continued improvements, even encouraging the utility to speed up
some planned projects and move ahead with a flood warning system
funded with FEMA grants.
Especially in growing
cities where expanding impervious areas shunt more water volume
into already overburdened drainage channels and storm sewers, adequate
flood control and floodplain management is an evermore criticaland
expensiveneed. As those who've gone through the process
of trying to build a stormwater utility have noted, nothing rallies
public support like a major flood.
Send
Janice an email |